Monday, October 15, 2007

Schools - Then and Now

This is the message that apparently a Secondary School staff in the Midlands voted unanimously to record on their school telephone answering machine.

This is the actual answering machine message for the school. It came about because they implemented a policy requiring students and parents to be responsible for their children's absences and missing homework. The school and teachers are now being threatened with legal action by some parents who want their children's failing marks changed to passing marks - even though those children were absent 15-30 times during the term and did not complete enough schoolwork to pass their various key stages.

The message:

'Hello! You have reached the automated answering service of your school. In order to assist you in connecting to the right member of staff, please listen to all the options before making a selection:

* To lie about why your child is absent - Press 1


* To make excuses for why your child did not do his/her work - Press 2

* To complain about what we do - Press 3

* To swear at staff members - Press 4

* To ask why you didn't get information that was already enclosed in your Newsletter and several letters posted to you - Press 5

* If you want us to bring up your child - Press 6

* If you want to reach out and touch, slap or hit someone - Press 7

* To request another teacher, for the third time this year - Press 8


* To complain about bus transport - Press 9

* To complain about school lunches - Press 0

LASTLY:


* If you realize this is the real world and your child must be accountable and responsible for his/her own behaviour, class work, homework and that it's not the teachers' fault for your child's lack of effort: Hang up and have a really wonderful day.

* If you want this in other languages, you must be in the wrong country. This is England.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Unfortunately, that is what our we have come to these days. There are some dedicated teachers out there and sometimes they are the ones who get into trouble for caring for their students. They are blamed for things that are beyond their control. While there are exceptions (every now and then you may get a teacher who just does not live up to your expectations as an educator), I believe there many more teachers who go the extra mile for their students. Their undying dedication is so often overlooked.

By the way, I have noticed how student problems are dealt with in school these days too. Well, at least in the States. We have certainly come a long way from our simpler days. MsJ of Inconditus sent me this article last week which illustrates what I mean. It is funny but sadly true to some extent. The age of innocence and simplicity is gone.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Subject: School 1967 vs. 2007

Scenario: Jack goes quail hunting before school, pulls into school parking lot with shotgun in gun rack.


1967 - Vice principal comes over to look at Jack's shotgun. He goes to his car and gets his shotgun to show Jack.
2007 - School goes into lock down, and FBI is called. Jack is hauled off to jail and never sees his truck or gun again. Counselors called in for traumatized students and teachers.

Scenario: Johnny and Mark get into a fistfight after school.

1967 - Crowd gathers. Mark wins. Johnny and Mark shake hands and end up best friends. Nobody goes to jail; nobody is arrested; nobody is expelled.
2007 - Police called. SWAT team arrives. Johnny and Mark are arrested and charged with assault. Both are expelled even though Johnny started it.

Scenario: Jeffrey won't be still in class, disrupts other students.

1967 - Jeffrey sent to office and given a good paddling by the principal. He returns to class, sits still, and does not disrupt class again.
2007 - Jeffrey is diagnosed with ADD and given huge doses of Ritalin. Becomes a zombie. School gets extra money from state because Jeffrey has a learning disability.

Scenario: Billy breaks a window in his neighbor's car and his Dad gives him a whipping with his belt.

1967 - Billy is more careful next time, grows up normal, goes to college, and becomes a successful businessman.
2007 - Billy's dad is arrested for child abuse. Billy is placed in foster care and joins a gang. State psychologist tells Billy's sister that she remembers being abused herself, and their dad goes to prison. Billy's mom has affair with psychologist.

Scenario: Mark gets a headache and takes some aspirin to school.

1967 - Mark shares aspirin with principal out on the smoking dock.
2007 - Police called. Mark is expelled from school for drug violations. Car is searched for drugs and weapons.

Scenario: Pedro fails high school English.

1967 - Pedro goes to summer school, passes English, goes to college.
2007 - Pedro's cause is taken up by state. Newspaper articles appear nationally explaining that teaching English as a requirement for graduation is racist. ACLU files class action lawsuit against state school system and Pedro's English teacher. English banned from core curriculum. Pedro is given a diploma anyway but ends up mowing lawns for a living because he cannot speak English.

Scenario: Johnny takes apart leftover firecrackers from 4th of July, puts them in a model airplane paint bottle, blows up a red ant bed.

1967 - Ants die.
2007 - Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco a and Firearms, Homeland Security, and FBI called. Johnny is charged with domestic terrorism. The FBI investigates parents; siblings are removed from home; computers confiscated. Johnny's dad goes on a terror watch list and is never allowed to fly again.

Scenario: Johnny falls while running during recess and scrapes his knee. He is found crying by his teacher, Heather. Heather hugs him to comfort him.

1967 - In a short time, Johnny feels better and goes on playing.
2007 - Heather is accused of being a sexual predator and loses her job. She faces three years in state prison. Johnny undergoes five years of therapy.

46 comments:

Salt N Turmeric said...

hi JT, sorry i have been mia for a while. with my frens here and also the raya thingy, there just seem to not be enuf time. tq for the lovely raya wish. i hope ud be able to visir my blog soon. kerp is having the same prob too.
abt the school, its like di telan mati emak, di buang mati bapak.

Lee said...

Hello JT, I'm back! Sure enjoyed reading this post of yours.
Makes me wonder about my time school days when there were teachers who walked around with a very long ruler in their hands, or a 4 feet Manau rattan cane hanging in the principal's office.
I experienced teachers who can put Clint Eastwood to shame with their accurate aiming of chalks at our heads should we be talking when he's talking.
And my handwriting certainly improved with untold number of exercise books I used up in writing out, "I must not hide my friends shoes in class", or "I must not bring snakes to school". And here I'm not talking of 500 lines...double that! Ha ha.
Oh well, times sure have changed.
You have a nice day, JT, Lee.

Nightwing said...

Hi JT,

Thanks for sharing the posting. Agree with the then and now scenario.

U have a good week now.

Anonymous said...

Hi JT

Just dropped by to say hello and to let you know you have an insightful blog. An enjoyable read!

Samad Torpedo

Anonymous said...

Hi Jacqui

Just dropped by to say hello and to say that you have an insightful blog. Fun and enjoyable to read

winniethepooh said...

sad but true..that is how the world is now. is this more apparent in the 'western' countries than in the 'eastern' countries? back home (in sg), parents still can discipline children by hitting with ruler or beat bumbum..western countries, they will call it child abuse, and parents can be punished instead!

everything seems to turn into mountain from that little molehill thing..

*shake head shake head*

J.T. said...

Hello Princess Farina

I am a little hopeless with some Malay proverbs these days. :)
Would you mind explaining the meaning of "telan mati emak, di buang mati bapak"? I heard it before but I have forgotten what it means.

So Kerp is also having trouble getting into your blog. At least I am not alone there. I thought something was wrong with my computer/connection. I hope I will be able to access your blog soon.

Take care and cheers! Hope you had a good Raya celebration in the O.C.

J.T. said...

Hi U.Lee,

So good to see you back again.

Speaking of your memories of school days when teachers walked around with 'rotans', I believe up to about the mid-80s, some schools were still practicing public caning. That certainly kept some students in line.

Oh yes, and that punishment of writing many lines is a classic. Our handwriting certainly improved with that 'exercise'. haha

I will drop by your blog as soon as I can. :)

J.T. said...

Hi Nightwing

That scenario certainly shows a huge difference in a glance, doesn't it? We did not feel the change because it slowly developed over the years.

Hope you had a good Raya celebration.

J.T. said...

Hello Samad Torpedo

Welcome to my blog. Thanks for the compliments. Hope to see you around.

P.S. Looking forward to reading more about your job. :) Interesting.

J.T. said...

Hi Winnie

I agree that these drastic changes in the school systems are more obvious in the western countries.

I suppose over time, some authorities have drawn a very thin line between child abuse and the right of a parent to keep his/her child in line.

You have a good week, Winnie.

Odele Souza said...

Hello Jacqueline,
Nice post.
When you have time, see David Santos' blog. There is a post regarding Flavia. And it is written in English, Spanish, French and Germany.

And how about you? I hope everything is OK.

J.T. said...

Hello Odele

Glad to see you here again. Everything has been ok here. Some days I take time off from blogging to see to other errands. Seems like ever since I returned to the States, times flies by even faster. :)

I will go over to David's blog in a minute. Thanks for informing me.

Hope all is well with you. Take care. *hugs*

Pi Bani said...

Scenario: Student gets whacked by his teacher for being naughty in school.
1967 - Student goes home, tells his parents he got whacked by his teacher. Parents give student another whacking for bringing shame to the family.
2007 - Student goes home, tells his parents he got whacked by his teacher. Parents go to school to whack the teacher.

J.T. said...

Hi Pi

hahaha... that's funny. Times have really changed, haven't they?

Anyway, I hope you are enjoying your Hari Raya holidays.

Anonymous said...

Thing have gone haywire haven't they? Why can't we simply revert to the 1967 scenarios you picture in the post? I guess times have changed, right? Sigh...

Daphne Ling said...

Hi JT,

Haha! That was funny...but in a somewhat sad way...We are paranoid huh?

The Secondary School in the Midlands were damn funny though...

I have one question...I am a little confused:-

"State psychologist tells Billy's sister that she remembers being abused herself, and their dad goes to prison."

Er, who got abused? Billy's sister, or the psychologist? "Their dad" refers to Billy-and-his-sister's dad, right?

Sorry if it is a silly question =)

pearly said...

JT darling :
If I don't see you around I do know you must be busy ... I pop around here to read , just didn't leave my comment . do thinking of you all the time .
I got to wait the post men in UK no more ON STRIKE there want more pay hhhahaha poor us no post and can't send post out too.
will send thing over just wait for the surprise xxxxxxxxx

WP said...

How true...it all goes to show that what kids need is love and a sound whacking if they misbehave.

Rita Ho said...

Hi Jacqui ... your post is the 2nd school shocker for me today. I just read that some school in Portland, Maine has decided to distribute contraceptive pills to 11-13 year old kids and they need not get parents' consent! What are these so-called educators thinking these days?

At this rate, we have to wonder if progress, freedom and rights is really worth fighting for in the end.

I like your new profile picture, great smile. :)

Anonymous said...

Hi J.T.,

The 1967 vs 2007 is so true. My hubby grew up during that era and never heard of school security. Received a lot of beatings from his dad and no one reported them. How the world has change. We have to actually watch how we speak now, if not you will get sued.

Great post, JT. Take care.

Pak Zawi said...

j.t.
Sorry for being late in putting my 2 sen worth of thoughts at your latest post.
Been observing the alarming scenario at the local school scenes. School children killing another child over a handphone. The father of the killer child aint any better than the child so it's only natural that his son did what he did. Can we blame the teachers and the school for such misbehavior? Things dont make sense anymore.

J.T. said...

Hi Bangkai

Times have really changed. Reverting, somehow, is so hard to grasp because most of us want to keep moving forward. So, there is a price to pay for being 'modern'.

Have a good weekend. :)

J.T. said...

Hi Daphne

You know what? I admit that line is very confusing. But I think they are poking fun at authorities who have a way of 'making up' stories to make a case.

So in this case, it is not really Billy's sister who remembers being abused rather the psychologist 'nudges' the girl to remember being abused. Confusing?

Whenever something tragic happens here, the news tend to sensationalise it so much that most people involved in a tragedy have their backgrounds and histories dugged up, checked and discussed on TV. Suddenly, we get people who have "new memories" of the victim or criminal.

That is my take, anyway. :)

J.T. said...

Hi Pearly

You're such a sweetheart. You haven't forgotten about that package. Thank you so much. We will just have to wait for the postmen to end the strike. Don't worry about it. I can wait. :)

I have decided to go back to cross stitching. So now, I am dividing up my time to fit in sewing too. So I blog when I can.

Hope you had a wonderful holiday in Holland.

J.T. said...

Hi WP

That is true - a good balance is required.

Thanks for your thoughts. :)

J.T. said...

Hello Rita

Wow...contraceptive pills given to 11-13 year old kids without needing parents' consent. That is a shocker. :0

Don't parents have rights over their children anymore?

I guess this is price of progress, freedom and rights.

J.T. said...

Hi Dawn

Yeah, that school security thing is everywhere. They even have metal detectors for 'notorious' public schools.

Remember when we got by with just prefects and teachers being the school's security? Times have changed, indeed.

And you are right, we have to be careful with what we say these days because we live in a suing world. Many people have become over sensitive. I am sure you have seen all the past and recent sensitivities on the news (here in the States). :)

J.T. said...

Rita ... I forgot to mention this earlier - Thank you for your lovely compliment. :)

J.T. said...

Hi Zawi

Nice to see you here again. I thought you would have taken a longer Raya break. Don't worry about being late here. I am taking my time blogging these days.

I did not know that the local (Malaysian) school scene was getting dangerous too. Things certainly don't make sense these days.

It should be as simple as parents taking responsibilties for their own children but somehow, in some cases, blame goes back to the teachers and schools.

Angel Eyes said...

Hi dear!

I'm back from my raya hols! So sleepy today when i first entered the office. Dang!

You have a great weekend ya? Cheers

Makcik Runner said...

thats what i call evolution!

nice postings!

Bee Ean said...

Wow what a huge change. We are living in a world that is harder and harder to deal with.

J.T. said...

Hello Angel Eyes

Oh! you're back - obviously still in the holiday mood. :)

Thanks for dropping by and you have a good weekend too (you will be all fresh and ready for Monday).

Cheers!

U-Jean said...

selamat hari hartal. i've posted something on my blog about it. do check it out. it is your right as a malaysian to know... thanks...

david santos said...

Hello!
Fantastic work!
You are Master!
Thank you and have a good weekend

pearly said...

wow ! who that pretty women .... oh I see is JT ..... love the picture you post on the blog lovely xxxxxx

yes !have lot of fun time in Holland you must read wat up it will a big surprise wat I get in holland hhehe.
you wouldn't belive it

J.T. said...

Hi KC

Glad to see you are back.

Thanks for summing my post up in one word. (I could have used that as my title). :D

J.T. said...

Hello Bee

Seems like the price we pay for progress is more complications in this world.

P.S. I bet the people before our time said the same thing too. :)

Thanks for your thoughts.

J.T. said...

Hello U-Jean

Welcome to my blog. :)

Thanks for posting that video on your blog. It is good to know what took place on this day 60 years ago.

J.T. said...

Hello David

Thanks for dropping by again and for the lovely compliments.

I am happy that you have a story about Flavia and Odele's battle for her daughter in your blog. It helps bring Odele's fight worldwide.

You do great work, David. God bless you.

J.T. said...

Hi Pearly dear

awww.. thank you for the compliments, my dear. Appreciate it very much. That was taken in 2005. I may have added a few more wrinkles to my face since then. hahaha

OK, I will come by your blog and read what you did and got in Holland. :)

You take care.

zorro said...

Tele-voce message: there goes eyeballto eyeball communication!I suppose for every button u press there will be a pre-recorded answer.Poop?

Have be sometime....how are u doing?

J.T. said...

Hi Zorro

Such is our life in a modern world. Automation has taken over face to face communication. Well, not in the case of web cameras. Though the other person is not there in the flesh, we can still see the other person's face. :)

Anyway, glad to see you here again after so long. I have been busy and a little tied up with chores. We moved back to the States at the end of August and I am taking my time sorting things out.

I have been a silent reader in your blog as well as some others for a while. Sometimes I just cannot get my thoughts together to put in a comment. I've been distracted since our move.

Hope all is well with you.

Cheers!

Anonymous said...

Brilliant juxtaposition, telling reminder of how much progress has regressed us as people.

Now, i'm starting to think of Malaysian examples...heh heh!

J.T. said...

Hi Galadriel

Nice to see you here again.

I bet you have already come up with some brilliant Malaysian examples of how regressed some people have become by now. ;) (some even behave like 'monkeys') hahaha